Friday, July 01, 2005

How to Fix It?

In the comments to the last post, That Girl brings up exactly the kind of exception I mentioned in passing: her son's school is failing him miserably, and even putting him in physical danger, and the efforts she has made to change the situation haven't made a bit of difference. If I were her, I'd be yanking my kid out of school so fast that heads would spin, and, if I had any money or resources (or could get someone to take the case pro bono), I'd be filing a lawsuit, too, despite my general antipathy to the notion that litigation is the way to solve problems. From a different angle, That Girl's predicament actually reinforces my original argument--that good, free, public schools should be available to all kids. Not only is her kid not getting that, he's getting the opposite of that.

There are a number of roots to this problem. First off, the school year as we all know it is based on a no-longer-relevant agrarian calendar: summers off is a relic of a time when all hands were necessary to work the farms, and, until the 1920s, a majority of Americans lived in rural areas. (In 1910, 45.6% of the popuation was urban, and by 1920, 51.2% was urban.) A second population factor, along with the migration to urban areas, was the influx of immigrants at the turn of the last century. There was tremendous urgency around "Americanization" and assimilation of immigrants, and the public schools were regarded as one of the primary means for that socialization.

Then we have an assortment of roots related to teachers. I don't have the space to go into all of it here, but the four most important factors were (a) increased need for teachers, as populations grew; (b) the desire to pay teachers as little as possible, even while requiring extensive qualifications; (c) an effort to "Taylorize" teachers' work, thereby reducing their autonomy and making them subordinate to school boards and the businessmen who typically served on those boards; and (d) a running debate (which continues to this day) about whether teachers should have subject-level expertise or should focus on pedagogy (i.e., teaching per se). (My friend A, for example, despite having a Ph.D. in political science and extensive teaching experience, including experience developing and teaching his own courses, must go through several years of pedagogical schooling in order to be qualified to teach elementary or high school in New York.) In the 1930s, single females were urged to quit their jobs so that married males (who had families to support) could have those jobs; in many areas, women were expected to quit their jobs when they married, and certainly if they were pregnant.

In many ways, the situation faced by teachers is analogous to the situation faced by baseball players. That is, baseball owners maintained such a hold on players, through the reserve clause, for so long, such that when the players finally organized, the situation had become much more acrimonious than it might otherwise have become. In both cases, the people in charge thought they had a stranglehold over the workers, they never dreamed the workers would ever revolt, and they responded badly when the revolution finally occurred. In both cases, the mistrust and acrimony lasted for many years, and the workers ended up with many more concessions (including some that are arguably detrimental to the overall profession) than they might have obtained if the owners/school boards had been more reasonable earlier in the process. For teachers, although this has not meant much in terms of compensation, it has meant that it's much more difficult to get rid of bad teachers. At the same time, typically the only way for a teacher to make more money is to become an administrator: this is not an effective way to keep good teachers in the classroom, teaching. (There was a case in the Chicago suburbs a few years ago, where a principal was encouraging cheating. As punishment, she was "demoted" to teaching.)

And, really, teachers don't make that much, given that a four-year degree is usually the minimum acceptable qualification, given that salaries are generally capped at a certain level, and given the difficulty of the work (yes, I think being a good teacher is very hard work). According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Kindergarten teachers made an average of $43,530, elementary school teachers made $44,960, middle school was $45,600, and secondary school was $47,810. If we made school a year-round thing, and paid teachers accordingly, the salaries would be $58,040, $59,946, $60,800, and $63,746. (Average salary overall for college graduates was $45,400 in 1999.) That step alone--making school year-round, and increasing teachers' salaries to account for the extra work--would cost significant bucks.

A second step would be to reduce class sizes. Here's some research on the subject. (There's also evidence from several studies in there showing that reducing class sizes also reduces the gaps between racial groups pretty significantly.) This, too, costs money.

A third issue facing schools is the question of from where the money will come. In many (most?) places, school funding is a function of the local tax base. That means that wealthy districts will (be able to) spend much more per pupil than poorer districts, which has the long-term effect of further cementing inequalities. The wealthy-suburbs/poor-city issue becomes even more pronounced (which is another reason why suburbs get on my nerves--they do not contribute enough to the metropolitan area as a whole).

I don't know the answers--and I certainly haven't identified all of the questions. What I do know is that education is more important than anything else (yay Larry!). If you can get an education, you can envision, and then make real, a better life for yourself. If you're stuck in a crumbling school, with overwhelmed (or just plain bad) teachers and overcrowded classrooms and inadequate supplies, not to mention parents who don't know how to (or simply cannot) improve your situation, then you are screwed. A free society cannot survive if its citizens are subjugated by their own ignorance.

6 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi :)

You have a great blog! Keep up the great work, and I'll be sure to visit regularly.

I have a elementary education degree online related site, check it out if you get some time!

Look forward to reading more of your insightful post!

9:36 PM  
Anonymous Teachers said...

Betty Tesh here with a few hints for new Teachers...

You're going to be a great teacher. You've got knowledge, enthusiasm, desire, motivation. What you don't have is experience.

And experience makes the difference between a potentially great teacher and a comfortably great teacher.

We've got over 68 combined years of experience to share, which is what we've done in...

"The Handy-Dandy Desktop Mentor."

No esoteric teaching methods. No field studies or carefully calibrated experiments. Just down-to-earth, helpful hints and suggestions to help you survive your first (few) years as a teacher.

We warn you about common pitfalls, give suggestions for getting along with fellow teachers, toss out a few classroom management techniques, offer advice on dealing with parents, and share secrets on organizing some of that "stuff" you've suddenly acquired.

If what you want is dull, dry treatise on pedagogy, or if you need a heavy meal of ibids and op.cits laced with quotes from learned professors of education, this book's not for you. It's quick and easy reading, a bit light-hearted, but as serious as an air strike about helping you bet the teacher you know you were meant to be.

A handbook for initially licensed, novice and beginning teachers that shares classroom management ideas, tips for getting along with educational personnel, suggestions for dealing with parents, and advice that good mentoring
teachers share for success in the classroom, written with humor by experienced educators.

As a new teacher, you won’t be doing battle with a supreme Evil like Sauron or traveling into the Cracks of Doom like Frodo Baggins and Samwise Gamgee, but like those two Hobbits, you are ‘expected to find a way...’ (Book IV, Chpt. 3) A way to make learning fun, but keep control of the classroom; a way to reach thirty different children with thirty different learning styles, a way to teach whole-heartedly while fielding a barrage of forms, procedures, expectations and instructions.

"The Handy-Dandy Desktop Mentor." is available at my site for new Teachers.

4:50 AM  
Anonymous Postsecondary Biological Sciences Teachers said...

Hi Emma Goldman,

As a result of reading your blog "this post", I think you will discover my site on Highest Wages In All States will be a great help.

To illustrate our diverse range of wages information, here are some of the latest search terms that located our site ...

Postsecondary Art Teachers Wages
Postsecondary Drama Teachers Wages
Postsecondary Space Sciences Teachers Teachers Wages
Postsecondary Marine Sciences Teachers Wages
Postsecondary Atmospheric Sciences Teachers Wages
Audio-visual Collections Specialists Wages
Postsecondary Biological Sciences Teachers Wages
Postsecondary Business Teachers Wages
Postsecondary Chemistry Teachers Wages
Postsecondary Communications Teachers Wages
Postsecondary Computer Science Teachers Wages
Postsecondary Criminal Justice Teachers Wages.

We have over 200 "have to read" career and wages articles in addition to many other interesting subjects in our Wages For All Occupations site.

Best Regards
Emily

8:46 AM  
Anonymous Postsecondary Psychology Teachers said...

Hello Emma Goldman,

After reading your blog "this post", I believe you will find the wages information on my site about Jobs With Best Wages to be very helpful.

To give you an idea of our wide range, some of the recent searches that found our site included ...

Postsecondary Religion Teachers Wages
Postsecondary Physics Teachers Wages
Postsecondary Political Socience Teachers Wages
Postsecondary Teachers Wages
Preschool Teachers Wages
Postsecondary Psychology Teachers Wages
Postsecondary Recreation & Fitness Studies Teachers Wages
Secondary School Teachers Wages.

We have hundreds of "must read" articles on wages and careers and many other topics in our Top Career Wages site.

Kind Regards
Emily

10:46 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

hi, i am learning about blogs and like what you did in yours, I have a blog about information. PLease come visit.

12:05 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

WOW WHATS NEXT>>>Live Your Life With A Little Daily Motivation.. Do we seek self empowerment Daily,weekly or yearly. I have been interested in working and self empowerment for years now. I am driven to success by the master teachers from the past. I really enjoy people like Wayne Dyer, Greg Vanden Berge and Tony Robbins. Im writing to this blog for selfish reasons, I want to see everyone live the life of their dreams. I am Living my life to the fullest and it is due to a book writen by Greg Vanden Berge . Master Goal Achiever and Author of Start Living Your Dreams Today.. A Great Book from the masters.. I hope you enjoy the book as much as I did..

6:46 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home